Google has insisted it wants to see the confidential data that its rivals offered to the US Department of Justice in help of an antitrust case towards the tech big.

In a court docket submitting [PDF] final week, the search engine behemoth mentioned it wants the knowledge to put together a correct protection to Preise that it has engaged in “anti-competitive and exclusionary practices” to defend its efficient monopoly.

Google needs two of its legal professionals to have full entry to all the things that others – together with Microsoft, Amazon, Oracle, AT&T and Comcast – have despatched to the DoJ.

But the federal government is opposed to the thought and claims in its personal court docket submitting [PDF] that disclosing the knowledge would “undermine third parties’ confidence in the treatment of their confidential information, chill third-party cooperation in current and future government investigations, and unfairly advantage Google in the marketplace if third-party confidential information is disclosed or used.”

Bill Gates

Today’s tech giants will not be as naive as I used to be in DoJ dealings, says former Microsoft chief Bill Gates


The two sides had a primary convention name over the case on October 30 the place they agreed on the overall phrases of how to proceed with the case however a right away sticking level got here with data disclosed to the federal government by different tech firms used to bolster the DoJ’s antitrust case towards Google.

The authorities has proposed that the knowledge be cut up into two varieties – confidential and extremely confidential – with the extremely confidential stuff by no means being seen by Google, or its in-house legal professionals. Google, unsurprisingly, needs to know precisely what its rivals have been saying about it and claims that the method “would create an unnecessary two-tiered system of confidentiality and would prohibit disclosure of significant third-party information to any Google in-house attorney.” Google additionally claims that the recommended method creates “wholly unreasonable restrictions” on its legal professionals.

The DoJ has proposed that Google have a single lawyer that may view the confidential – however not extremely confidential – materials. Its exterior counsel would nevertheless have entry. Google needs two in-house legal professionals given full entry. It affords the safeguards that these legal professionals is not going to be concerned in industrial decision-making for Google for 2 years after the case ends and can solely entry the fabric in a safe area – both bodily or digital – in addition to promise to report any suspected disclosure of protected data.


Google can be sad that the DoJ’s proposed system wouldn’t permit it to object to materials or to have advance discover if the knowledge was utilized in one other future case. “Just as third parties are afforded an opportunity to be heard here, so too should Google be provided notice if Plaintiffs intend to disclose Google’s information to others,” it argues.

The DoJ’s primary argument towards Google having the ability to see “highly confidential” data is that it is probably going to comprise “strategic plans related to rival voice assistants, and other commercially sensitive information” which Google may use to its personal benefit.

There are quite a few precedents that make it probably that Google is not going to get what it needs, essentially the most important being that through the massive Microsoft antitrust case – which this case is essentially primarily based on – the Beast of Redmond was not allowed to see extremely confidential recordsdata; they had been solely made out there to its exterior counsel.

There’s additionally the truth that Google has used the identical rule to its benefit up to now – and towards Microsoft. The Reg’s personal Thomas Claburn spent six years chasing down the small print of Google’s grievance towards Microsoft over Windows desktop search earlier than lastly being given, in 2011, web page after web page of redacted textual content: nice massive gray bins protecting all the things.

What goes round, Google… ®