Brent Kolatalo in his studio.
Photo: Courtesy of Brent Kolatalo

Mixing is one in all the most undersung jobs in music. While the artists and producers get the credit score, the engineer’s work — taking a music’s uncooked supplies corresponding to vocal tracks and instrumentals, and sprucing them into one thing that sparkles — is usually what makes a very good music nice, or an ideal music traditional. It is usually a mammoth technological enterprise that entails shaping a whole lot of disparate sounds into one cohesive melody, a job that even the most cutting-edge expertise can’t all the time assist. Beyond having a very good ear and the ability set to regulate audio ranges, engineers must be artistic, prepared to take each route and dangers. There’s balancing the explicit calls for of artists, their groups, and their labels, all whereas pushing by means of the strains of fast deadlines whereas battling self-doubt.

“Sometimes you will hear something and just think, ‘Man, the production is amazing,’ but what you might not know is that behind the scenes, a mixer was given something they didn’t really have a lot to work with,” says Howard Redekopp, a Juno Award–successful producer and mixer who’s labored with Tegan and Sara, the New Pornographers, and lots of others. “She or he might have been frustrated going, ‘This is a brilliant song, but I wish that there were more ingredients,’ so they concoct parts or heavily manipulate what’s there to turn it into this magical thing. It goes the other way, too — a lot of great production can get lost if it goes through a meat-grinder mix.”

To perceive why that’s the case, we spoke with 9 outstanding combine engineers in numerous genres about the hardest songs they tackled, be it due to choosy performers or overwhelming stress — and, in a single case, an almost devastating fireplace.

The mixture of an unrealistic deadline and demo-itis (which is when the consumer falls in love with the sound of their demo) is a traditional recipe for a mixing nightmare. That’s what occurred to me once I was employed to combine “Borderline” for Gallant.

The music was set to be an unique single for Red Bull’s music label however they wanted the remaining combine turned in the subsequent day — no exceptions. It was already late night by the time I acquired the audio recordsdata and my directions had been to make it sound like the demo however extra alive and, after all, “better.” My anxiousness degree was fairly excessive already, however what put it into manic overdrive was realizing all the vocal recordsdata had been already drenched with reverbs and delays, and fully overly compressed. That’s mainly tying one arm behind the combine engineer’s again and nonetheless anticipating them to hit a homer towards Clayton Kershaw.  There wasn’t a lot I may do to it — the sound was locked in.

I attempted getting the uncooked vocal recordsdata however it was too late, so I combined what I had and hoped for the finest. After 14 hours, seven revisions, and the solar beginning to creep out, I began to comprehend my finest won’t be adequate this time. They ended up utilizing my instrumental combine for the music however went with the authentic demo vocal. It was a little bit of a Frankensteined model and, honestly, an ego blow. But they had been proud of the finish outcome and that’s all that mattered.

At the finish of the day, mixing is usually a very subjective factor, as a result of everybody has a unique definition of what technically sounds “better.” Your consumer could like an overcompressed, extraordinarily shiny vocal sound, and I would assume that’s the most ear-fatiguing sound in the world. But who’s actually proper in the finish? Well, the consumer is, and it’s your job to get no matter sound they’re listening to of their head.

I’ve a spot with a full studio in Playas, Ecuador, the place I’m going to work and rebalance. I’ve accomplished work from there for BTS and their label Big Hit, and two days after ending a monitor for an additional one in all their artists, TXT, a fireplace broke out on the 14th flooring of my constructing, instantly beneath us. Someone left an inexpensive cellphone charger plugged in for per week, it burned out the socket, and expanded from there. My spouse and I had been dwelling, we personal flooring 17 and 18, and as soon as I noticed smoke, I dropped all the pieces, grabbed her, ran out, and closed each fireplace door down 18 flights to the floor. We received out and watched the constructing burn — one other 5 minutes and we might’ve been trapped. My studio was effective — there was some smoke injury, our home windows cracked, and a few curtains melted. It’s a miracle extra of the constructing didn’t go up. Then the name got here to combine the BTS single “Interlude: Shadow,” and naturally they “need it right away.”

After the fireplace, the proprietor of a close-by suite on the seaside heard about it and let me keep there, proper on the water.  My studio was 18 flooring up with no working elevator or electrical energy. I moved my entire factor throughout the parking zone to the seaside, climbing up and down 18 flooring with heavy gear for 2 days. The seaside suite was like a reflective field that added reverb, so I soundproofed it as a lot as I may with cushions from my condominium and blankets that I hung on mic stands. It seemed ridiculous however it labored. Great headphones had been the true lifesaver.

Mixing in the room was nice, truly — the seaside view was exceptionally inspiring — however the actual problem past mixing in a reflective field is that “Interlude” has three distinct sections, and effectively over 100 tracks, so I mainly needed to combine three songs.  On high of all the different challenges, I had to determine how they’d go finest from one part to the subsequent with fully completely different sounds and vocals, so it was a number of time and care and referencing different BTS mixes I’d accomplished to verify it had the dramatic spirit of my favorites.

“Interlude: Shadow” options Suga, however I’ve labored on BTS tunes that showcase all seven members, so you’ll be able to think about leads, counter leads, background vocals, harmonies, counter harmonies, stacked by a number of singers and rappers. It will be north of 200 tracks to combine for one music — fortunately, their producers are genius and the entire group is extremely gifted and arranged. I really like these mixes, since you all the time need to be challenged to just be sure you’re pretty much as good as you assume you’re. Those are the tremendous checks. You simply work with it till every of the particular person sections looks like a document that sounds the manner you envisioned it to sound.

Ye and I’ve been working collectively since proper after Jay Z’s Die Blaupause. I received the name to combine “Stronger” on a Saturday night time: “Ye wants to go into the studio tomorrow. It’s the first single on the new album.” I attempt to not work on Sundays — that’s household day — however I went in and introduced my son, who was 4 or 5 at the time. He’s sitting subsequent to me — I let him play with a bucket of faders on the console that I wasn’t utilizing — and I dive in and blend it in a number of hours. Kanye listened to it a number of instances and goes, “Man, sounds great. Just send it to me,” so I did.

I went to New York to work with Alicia Keys for nearly a month and I’m pondering, I didn’t hear something from Ye’s camp, whether or not it was good or dangerous. That’s type of odd. Then I get a name, “Hey, man. We want to revisit ‘Stronger.’ Ye likes your mix but he wants to try a few other things.” I’m going in, be taught that he and Mike Dean, the co-producer, had added a number of synths, and I combine that. I get one other name per week later: “Can you do that again?” I did that about three or 4 instances. Two or three months later, they name me again and say, “He still wants to mess with it.” So, we return.

I’m sitting there, and I’ll always remember this second the place Ye is pacing proper behind me. I’m like, “Man, you’re making me really nervous. Will you just stop and sit and let’s just work on it?” And he’s like, “Man, it’s not right. It’s not right.” I gotta let you know, out of all the mixes I’ve ever accomplished, I’ve by no means, ever give up. But after so many updates, a lot chasing, I used to be actually about to inform him that I didn’t assume I used to be the proper man for the combine. I’m about to chop the wire once I hit the exterior button on the console and it occurred to play a unique model of the combine. As he’s pacing, he goes, “Wait, that’s it! What is that?” The file had the date on it and I’m like, “That was the first we mix we did on that Sunday.” He says, “That’s the mix!” Ten minutes later, I used to be accomplished.

It was irritating, however later, I discovered — I’m glad I didn’t know this at the time — that 12 individuals combined it and he was sad with all of them and the one I did in three hours ended up being the remaining. One factor about Ye is, he actually is a visionary. I feel, for him, it was extra about the journey of experimenting with different sounds and textures. That was what he needed to do creatively. I feel mine ended up being the winner as a result of I handled the pattern like an instrument — I did about 150 quantity and frequency tweaks so Ye’s voice is all the time the star however when he wasn’t saying something, it was the hypnotic pattern.

The problem was second-guessing your self by means of the course of. You undergo, “I suck. I am terrible. I can’t get it,” since you’re consistently looking for one thing that exists in another person’s thoughts. Then, abruptly, like the Red Sea elements and increase, there it’s. It’s fairly superb to expertise. Funny story, my spouse was in the automobile and my son was in the backseat, and “Stronger” got here on the radio. He saved saying, “Mom! I mixed this song!” So, the joke in the home is that, as a result of I gave him the console to play with, he “mixed” “Stronger.” It’s one in all my favourite songs ever.

This music was written simply after Shawn had launched his sophomore album, Erleuchten, and have become a radio single and the first monitor on the deluxe model. It was good to work in form of a vacuum with the timeframe, as a result of we had freedom to experiment. There had been no prompts on ending it, however it was a puzzle that took us six weeks to crack.

Part of that was as a result of the music was delivered to me in Pro Tools, which is form of the industry-standard software program however not one I usually use. I used to be manner out of my component however there was one thing about it that type of compelled me to pay attention extra. It’s such as you lose one sense and also you achieve one other.

Teddy Geiger was the fundamental producer, and once I received the music I’d say it was about 60 % accomplished. There had been six of us, together with Shawn, giving notes on all the revisions so it was an actual collaboration. I’ve my very own methods and concepts, however it’s about what the artist and the workforce need, so I adopted everybody’s options. The model that was given to me felt nice — it was clearly an ideal music, the efficiency was superb — however there was one thing about the sonics that weren’t gelling or feeling pure. We spent weeks experimenting with completely different mixtures of components and including issues and lowering issues — altering the place the kick drum got here in and the bridge and what ad-lib was interjecting at what level in the remaining refrain — there was so much to attempt, and we tried all of it.

Shawn is de facto good at tapping into what the listener goes to be drawn to the most. We ended up integrating a number of new vocal layers and ad-libs in the remaining refrain of the music, which weren’t recorded once we began doing the mixing. He was recording them in his condominium in Toronto and sending them to me through Dropbox. There was even a second the place we had been FaceTiming and I’d maintain my cellphone as much as my pc display screen so he may see me working Pro Tools. He can be like, “Wait, move it one bar left. Okay, add some delay,” like a digital in-person session.

The part that was the most complicated was what I’d name the post-chorus drop, the place the beat kicks in, there’s the acoustic guitar hook, and the chorus lyric, “There’s nothing holdin’ me back.” That part was the spot that felt the least compelling in the model as I began working on it, und über the part that wanted to be the largest. I’ve to offer Shawn credit score — about three-quarters of the manner into the course of, he mentioned, “Let’s just mute everything but these elements.” That was the rhythm guitar, the drums, the lead vocal, and that looping guitar hook. We tossed all the pieces else out the window and it simply got here alive. Finally, we knew it was proper.

Normally I’m a fairly quick mixer — I’m typically in the two-and-a-half to five-hour vary for a music, at the max. Walk the Moon’s “Anna Sun” took me days. It was a breakthrough music for Walk the Moon and actually set them up for his or her second album. I actually needed to knock it out of the park for them, and I feel we received there.

It took so long as it did as a result of the band’s A&R man, David Walter, got here to me with three completely different variations of the music. Two had been at the identical tempo however with completely different preparations, after which there was the band’s authentic demo, which was two bpm slower. There had been issues he appreciated from each model, however getting everyone enjoying the identical sections at the identical time at the identical tempo was a problem proper off the bat.

There was a fundamental monitor that we use most of the devices from — besides I used the intro drums from the demo. There was the video model, which was a unique association, which had some good keyboards and results. They had three completely different preparations of the bridge, and I appreciated elements of every one, however nonetheless not the entire bridge idea, so a few of that went into the outro. I had to make use of a time-stretch instrument, Pitch N’ Time, that allowed me to place the completely different sections in the identical bpm with out it sounding like grainy crap or a sped-up Chipmunks really feel. I feel it was most likely per week of going back-and-forth with David earlier than we received to indicate this Frankenmix to the band.

Around that very same interval, as a result of bands had been capable of document at dwelling, I’d get a number of labels going, “Well, we redid all this but there’s still stuff from the demo that we love. How can you make these two sound the same?” The simplest way is to offer me the demo elements! Here, we may preserve the skilled, large sound however nonetheless decide the demo elements that had been simply too uncooked. In this case, a number of that was the lead vocal. It’s that power — you’ve simply written the music and also you’re recording it for the first time.

Nick Petricca, the singer, had a sure pleasure there and generally that’s arduous to breed, particularly with a younger band. If I did my job proper, hopefully, no one may inform the distinction in the remaining combine. As I bear in mind, they had been excited to listen to all these components put collectively, as a result of I don’t assume they ever imagined that they may try this.

What makes a mixture actually good shouldn’t be the way you combine it, it’s the way you document it. That’s what I used to be taught by means of my dad [legendary guitarist and recording innovator Les Paul].

Once, I used to be doing a session with Aretha and the drummer Bernard Purdie’s mic fell on the hi-hat in the center of the take. I received up and I’m working to get in the studio and repair it. I’m going by Jerry Wexler, an enormous producer at Atlantic, and he turns to me and says, “Where are you going?” I say, “I’m gonna go fix the mic before we take the next one.” He mentioned, “That was it.” I stared at Wexler and thought he was insane, however they didn’t give a shit about imperfections. All they cared about was the way it felt.  Today, we’re getting additional and additional away from what occurs between the devices, and, with expertise, nearer and nearer to perfection. That shouldn’t get in the manner of music. That was a part of my studying course of.

The first music that got here to thoughts when fascinated with a troublesome combine was not the most tough — it was Roberta Flack’s “Killing Me Softly With His Song,” as a result of the label didn’t need to put it out. It was accomplished with mainly everyone in the room at the identical time with Roberta doing a pilot vocal. We did her lead and the backing vocals later. The magic in that room was one thing I skilled perhaps a dozen instances in my life. It went as clean as clean will be, and once we took it as much as the entrance workplace, they hated it. Roberta couldn’t stand it.

All of us had been sitting there like, “What did we do wrong? This is perfect.” The very first thing they mentioned was, “Oh, my God. The kick drum is way too loud!” That was their largest bitch. It’s humorous telling this story now when all music relies on the foot — the kick drum is the star and the visitor look is the artist. But again then, it was simply scary how the affect of it felt.

So, we had to return and remix it three or 4 extra instances, weeks of labor. We completed the different mixes, they usually mentioned, “Well, we’re gonna put out the original mix or we take it off the album.” And that kick was the entire key to the tune. That was it. That was the magic of it. That’s why, after we did all the different takes for them, we went again to the authentic. It was simply conventional and sensible, plain and easy. Roberta didn’t take care of it, however when she picked the Grammy up, it was the biggest concept she ever had.

As a mixing engineer, one in all my first purchasers was Diplo, and in the early 2010s, I began working with him on a number of initiatives. He’s an eclectic producer, leaping from super-pop songs to one thing very underground, and I’m very consistent with that strategy. I’m very glad to leap into completely different types, and with initiatives, I really want to grasp the story behind it, what the objective is. One of the first initiatives Diplo threw me was Snoop Dogg’s Reinkarniert, which he was producing. He needed me to place my stamp on it as Snoop went from West Coast hip-hop to dancehall, however first I needed to get the job.

They did the single “Lighters Up” and Snoop mentioned, “Look, I worked with an engineer that did everything for me from back in the Dre time to everything.” The label had engineers and there was me, so Snoop determined to have 4 mixes of the music accomplished, decide the finest, and from that time on, that man would combine the whole album. Usually, I don’t do these sort of spec issues, however with my Italian perspective, I type of appreciated the strain to go in there, in the darkish on this new type, and attempt to convey a unique spirit and persona to the album.

On that music, I changed the kick drum and the 808 on the refrain as a result of I felt it improved the high quality. I didn’t say, “By the way, I’m going to replace your drums” — I simply did it and despatched the remaining combine in. They did a listening session, Snoop was impressed, and I received the album. I gained their belief. Back then, I had a small studio in an workplace space of Vegas, working on a sluggish pc from like 8 p.m. to six in the morning, simply so I didn’t disturb my neighbors. For this mission, I received a quicker pc and labored for over two months with an area engineer in Jamaica, accumulating stems of tracks to get a really feel for the music and perceive the imaginative and prescient of Snoop Lion.

Overall, they gave me a possibility to do a really natural, authentic combine, as a result of they recorded very historically on a classic board and let me usher in my fashionable methods to one thing very out of my consolation zone. Snoop has a really open-minded strategy and it’s purposely not very technical — extra like a sense and a vibe. His trademark is his voice, so that they needed to make it possible for was all the time at the entrance of the combine, even when he was whispering, however apart from that, they allowed us to make use of our creativity. I used to be working remotely however everybody there loved the better of Jamaica, smoking and going to distant locations. You can see that in the documentary and listen to my mixes in the background. The album ended as much as have a Grammy nomination for Best Reggae Album, one thing that nobody concerned in the mission anticipated. It was a particular second for my profession and stays one in all my finest reminiscences.

As a producer-mixer, I don’t all the time combine the stuff that I produce, and I don’t all the time produce the stuff that I combine. But the lion’s share of my work is each, and that was the case with Tegan and Sara’s “Walking With a Ghost.”

On So Jealous, I used to be a co-producer with John Collins from the New Pornographers and Dave Carswell, who had accomplished the earlier Tegan and Sara information. The label needed to spend cash and make the album sound costlier however not slick, they usually thought I may assist stroll the line. We tag-teamed the songs, as a result of three producers couldn’t be in the identical room, and I bear in mind taking “Walking With a Ghost.”

I don’t bear in mind the recording a part of it, however I bear in mind modifying it like that was my child and I didn’t actually need anyone else to the touch it. It’s these scrappy guitars, the vocals are repetitive and double-, triple-tracked, and the kind is atypical with the refrain. It’s simply this bizarre factor that has a fluid feeling and, in mixing, I made it actually shiny and crisp. I bear in mind Dave saying, “Those guitars are too bright. They’re killing me,” so I tamed them down a bit, as a result of normally when somebody has a robust opinion, they’re proper. The guitars had been perhaps slightly bit too searing and type of painful. Because the vocals type of reside in that very same form of zone. And even once I did type of tame it down, I bear in mind, nonetheless, Dave simply being like, “I don’t know, I mean, it sounds good but it’s just too bright for me. I’m not into it. I don’t like it.”

My strategy to mixing is all the time discovering what makes one thing particular and distinctive and drawing that out, somewhat than “let’s just try to make this sound really good.” What is the response we’re making an attempt to evoke in the listener? Let’s actually seize onto that and push that envelope so far as you’ll be able to. If it means brightened singing and annoying guitars, try this. I used to be making an attempt to embrace the bizarre and have simply sufficient edginess to it that folks would cock their ears and go, “What’s this?”

At the finish, I went to Tegan’s condominium in Vancouver earlier than mastering and we had been placing the order of the songs collectively. Sara was on speakerphone and somebody mentioned, “Okay, what about ‘Walking With a Ghost’?” And I’m like “What do you mean?” they usually’re like, “Well, nobody wants it on the record.”

The problem was that there was one other music on the document, “We Didn’t Do It,” that type of has the same form of uneven beat. It lived in the same world as “Walking With a Ghost” however it had slightly bit extra, I consider a standard construction. It was a warmer-sounding music. Just type of a bit punchier, a bit hotter, however it simply wasn’t as fascinating. I mentioned, “Look, here’s how strongly I feel about it. I’m really grateful to have been a part of this record but I’m willing for you to strike my name from the credits if you don’t put the song on there.” So they determined to go together with it. and it ended up being a turning level of their profession. That document, as a complete, garnered them a a lot larger viewers and allow them to tour longer and wider than they ever had.

“Transatlanticism” was only a bear to get it to really feel proper. Everything I had accomplished up till 2003 had been on tape, and with that music, we crammed up the 24 tracks on the tape machine fairly shortly. Still, it felt prefer it simply wasn’t sufficient. We had been beginning to lean into maximalism and I simply felt like there was much more there.

It needed some measurement at the ends that I couldn’t determine the right way to make room for, as a result of, at that time, I didn’t know something about computer systems. I ran a tough mixture of what we had by means of a chunk of half-inch tape then ran that tough combine to a brand new piece of multitrack tape, then crammed that up with guitars and with all the vocals at the finish, with simply no plan for the way I used to be gonna make all of it work. I had one tape machine — I couldn’t even play them each at the identical time. It simply become, “Actually, I don’t know how to do this at all,” so we ended up dumping it into Pro Tools. That was my very first foray into digital recording. I hated it, however there was no different selection.

There was some instrumental stuff that we had been all fairly into that we’d reference, like Explosions in the Sky or Godspeed You! Black Emperor, these actually epic atmospheric information. But these information don’t have vocals, so it was like, “How does this story work inside something that’s like a big, weird, fuzzy terrarium?” So we took it into Studio X in Seattle, which is now an Amazon constructing, and I spent 12 hours beating my head towards the wall, making an attempt to determine the right way to make all of it match collectively. And ultimately, it did. Because it’s so ensemble and gauzy, you’re massaging it, simply pushing issues round. It’s extra Monet than Rockwell.

The different factor that I spotted was that I truly didn’t have any concept the right way to take care of a full 48-channel board and get the music to unfold in a cinematic manner. I’m all the time capturing for information that sound nice, however extra importantly, simply fühle mich wirklich proper — one thing you’ll be able to actually sink into and let take over the expertise. I missed that on the first combine.  The density was all mistaken, it wasn’t clear. Sometimes these large songs fall by the wayside as individuals get into the album, and I simply knew this wasn’t a type of as a result of everyone was reacting to it so strongly in the studio. It felt particular.

I simply listened to it once more for the first time in years. Some of the placement decisions are fairly wild, however it was indie rock in 2003. In a contemporary combine, the vocals can be louder, and I want the bass was louder. I so seldom aspect with my work — I all the time really feel like there’s some rock that didn’t get turned over or some alternative that received missed, or options I didn’t incorporate as a result of I used to be insecure or for ego causes. But the feeling in “Transatlanticism” is de facto there. I used to be actually glad to listen to that.

Are you an engineer with an ideal hardest combine story to share? Let us know at